Tuesday, April 11, 2006

Dan Lucarini

I was given a book to read by one of my good friends. This book was written by Dan Lucarini and is titled Why I Left The Contemporary Music Movement. First I want to give a few historical facts. Mr. Lucarini started his music career in the Rock and Roll industry. He was a song writer/musician/vocalist. When he became a Christian when he was 23. After his conversion he found it hard to give up his rock music. However, he was able to fill this void with CCM. He became heavily involved in praise & worship and became a worship leader in the church he was attending. He says in this book that CCM and P&W music is divisive and the cause of many church splits. He was a part of three or four splits and blames CCM and the worship team’s lack of communication for all of them. He based this on the fact that CCM caused a huge rift because they wanted to quit singing traditional songs and leading a traditional service. He talks about the basis of CCM and the culture it is born out of. He claims that CCM P&W is based on immorality and selfishness. He is currently not involved in the music ministry of his church because he unintentionally brings this style to the music and he doesn’t believe this is the kind of worship God wants. In fact, he pretty much says that CCM P&W is not worship. Here is a man who was a part of this music culture and is now condemning it. I have not listened to CCM for a long time and have never enjoyed P&W. The main reason I didn't listen to these/this style had nothing to do with religion. It was more I just didn't like it anymore. In conclusion, I highly recommend the book. It has given me a different perspective on music in general.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

we had to read that book at Heritage. Interesting stuff. It's easier to hear someone who's been there himself.

one thing I found kinda funny bout your post was that he was "condemning" music you don't care for, and you say "so I highly recommend this book". Since you agreed w/ him in the first place, you'll recommend him huh. that's easy. what if you wouldn't have?
sorta amused me.
heidi

Glen Zehr said...

Wait a minute, I don't think I said that. I was saying what he said. I don't know if I agree with him or not. I found it hard to disagree in one sense because he was there and involved in it. However, he actually does not say it shouldn't be listened to. He says it shouldn't be used in church for worship. I recommend it because he was involved in this wave of CCM and it brings a prespective to that style of music that we as Mennonites do not have.
But, your right, I don't like CCM or P&W but I don't if you could tell that from my post. You know it because you know me....
Of course, I may be wrong......
Maybe you could tell.
Anyway, and so forth.....
GZ

Unknown said...

I just read the book and Googled "Dan Lucarini" so that is how I found your blog. If you don't mind I'll weigh in here.

I was a guitarist and vocalist on the worship team at one of my former churches. Instead of a rock&roll background, I come from a background of strictly hymns. Acapella hymns, no less. CCM/P&W music brought a depth and richness to my walk with God that I had never experienced growing up. It wasn't actually the music, per se, the music was simply one of the tools the Holy Spirit used in my walk with Christ. There have been many, many times when I wasn't on stage that I was on my face on the floor crying out to God while the rest of the team led worship. During worship I've received some of the most profound revelations, peace during confusion, direction, and just simply being in his presence where God was literally tangible to my senses. I highly recommend it! :) I believe God's requirements for worship are a surrendered, honest heart that's hungry for him.

Anonymous said...

Dan's book is full of holes. Too bad. He thinks that he has "cred" due to the fact that he once belonged to it.

In all honesty, Dan's sin, had to find a scape goat...and CCM provide that.

I used to think that Lucarini would see the light.

But he won't and that's ok. PRAISE God, that he only really reaches those that already agree with him. There are thousands of theologically grounded pastors that think otherwise.

Once again, we can only pray that his flawed exegesis stays contained within the small circle of ultra-fundamentalists.